Insight With Beth Ruyak

Hosted By Beth Ruyak

A daily, in-depth interview program providing context and background to the issues that face our region.

Schedule

Monday – Friday, 9 a.m. – 10 a.m. and 7 p.m. – 8 p.m.
on News Station

 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 

Ditching Daylight Saving Time: Pros And Cons

kengo / Flickr
 

kengo / Flickr

For those of you who hate being robbed an hour of sleep every spring, as you will this weekend when Daylight Saving Time takes effect, there is hope. A new bill by Assembly member Kansen Chu, D-San Jose, would end DST in California.

Chu’s press secretary Robert Mason says all the reasons for using DST no longer make sense. Voters approved Proposition 12 in 1949 to adopt DST because they wanted to conserve fuel and electricity. 

“But we’ve become so technologically advanced that these reasons are moot,” Mason said.

Mason points to correlative evidence showing lower workplace productivity, an increase in reported heart attacks, an increase in workplace injuries and an increase in traffic accidents when we switch between DST and Standard Time each year.

But David Prerau, author of the definitive book on the story of DST, "Seize the Daylight: The Curious and Contentious Story of Daylight Saving Time," says we shouldn’t throw out 240-plus days of benefits because of a couple weeks of negative consequences.

“Longer daylight hours in the summer help us stay active and healthy. It also leads to a decrease in traffic accidents and crime,” Prerau said.

In general, people prefer having more sun in the evening than in the early morning. It’s the switching back and forth that people despise. 

Sheila Danzig, creator of the time-conscious website www.standardtime.com, says 80 percent of the people she’s surveyed want DST year-round. Only 20 percent want Standard Time year-round.

“The problem is that states can’t adopt year-round DST. They can only reject it. So, given the choice, people want the solution that ends the springing forward and falling back,” Danzig said.

She thinks it’s possible California could join the ranks of states like Arizona and Hawaii, which have rejected DST, but she is pushing for a federal solution.

“Without a consistent federal decision, we’ll have poke-a-dotted time zones all over the country, which is something nobody wants,” she said.

Prerau agrees. He says the biggest problem with rejecting DST is losing consistency across state lines.

“Losing that consistency could hurt California businesses,” Prerau said. “Indiana ended its temporary rejection of DST because it was having a negative effect on businesses.”   

We’ll hear both sides of this issue and some history on today's Insight.  

James Morrison

Former Producer, Insight

James Morrison began his career at Capital Public Radio in 2007 as a news intern, first for All Things Considered then Morning Edition. In January 2011, Morrison was hired as part-time news producer and general assignment reporter.   Read Full Bio 

More From Insight With Beth Ruyak