Skip to content
CapRadio

CapRadio

signal status listen live donate
listen live donate signal status
listen live donate signal status
  • News
    • beats
    • State Government
    • Environment
    • Health Care
    • Business
    • Arts and Lifestyle
    • Food and Sustainability
    • PolitiFact California
    • California Dream
    • Videos
    • Photos
  • Music
    • genres
    • Classical
    • Jazz
    • Roots
    • Eclectic
    • Videos
    • Daily Playlist
  • Programs + Podcasts
    • news
    • Morning Edition
    • All Things Considered
    • Marketplace
    • Insight
    • California State of Mind
    • The View From Here
    • music
    • Acid Jazz
    • At the Opera
    • Classical Music
    • Connections
    • Excellence in Jazz
    • Hey, Listen!
    • Insight Music
    • K-ZAP on CapRadio
    • Mick Martin's Blues Party
    • Programs A-Z
    • Podcast Directory
  • Schedules
    • News
    • Music
    • ClassicalStream
    • JazzStream
    • Weekly Schedule
    • Daily Playlist
  • Community
    • Events Calendar
    • CapRadio Garden
    • CapRadio Reads
    • CapRadio Travels
    • Ticket Giveaways
  • Support
    • Evergreen Gift
    • One-Time Gift
    • Corporate Support / Underwriting
    • Vehicle Donation
    • Stock Gift
    • Legacy Gift
    • Endowment Gift
    • Volunteering
    • Benefits
    • Member FAQ
    • e‑Newsletter
    • Drawing Winners
    • Thank You Gifts
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Close Menu
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 

How Risky Was That Napa Party Gavin Newsom Attended?

Sunday, November 22, 2020 | Sacramento, CA
AP Photo/Jeff Chiu

Gov. Gavin Newsom wears a protective mask on his face while speaking to reporters at Miss Ollie's restaurant during the coronavirus outbreak in Oakland, Calif., Tuesday, June 9, 2020.

AP Photo/Jeff Chiu

By James Bikales, CalMatters

Just how risky was the birthday party that Gov. Gavin Newsom attended at a ritzy Napa Valley restaurant? 

According to a modeling tool, if held today, there’s an 11 to 12% chance — odds of about one in nine — that one of the dinner guests was infected with the coronavirus. 

The COVID-19 risk map, developed by Georgia Institute of Technology researchers, has been peer-reviewed and published in the highly esteemed science journal Nature. Using data on infections in each county, it calculates the risk that at least one afflicted attendee will be at an event of various sizes.

Based on current Napa County infections, the model calculates a 12% likelihood that one guest at an event of 10 people would have COVID-19. Using Sacramento County, where many of the guests were from, gives it an 11% chance. 

For context, a 10-person event in hard-hit Foster County, N.D. has an 81% chance of a guest at a party that size being infected.

Dr. Peter Chin-Hong, an infectious disease expert at the University of California, San Francisco, said the 11% risk figure “seems a little high,” but is “in the realm of possibility.”

“Models are great when you compare one thing to the other, but in terms of bringing an absolute number of risk, there are some limitations,” he said.

The Nov. 6 dinner attended by at least 12 people was celebrating the birthday of lobbyist Jason Kinney, a close friend of Newsom’s, according to the San Francisco Chronicle, which first reported the story Nov. 13. Newsom and his wife joined members of several other households at the event — including two California Medical Association executives — despite his administration urging against private gatherings of more than three households. 

There have been no reports of anyone at the party contracting the coronavirus.

Probability aside, many epidemiologists agree that dining out poses a high risk of infection, given that it places strangers in close proximity for extended periods, often without masks. 

Whether indoors or outdoors, dining in a restaurant is “amongst the riskiest things we do for COVID,” largely due to the inherently social nature of the activity, Chin-Hong said.

Studies appear to bear out the conclusion that the party at Michelin-starred French Laundry in Yountville put its guests at significant risk.

A CDC study published in September found that, of 314 adults showing COVID-19 symptoms, those who tested positive for the virus were twice as likely to have dined in a restaurant — whether seated indoors or outdoors — during the preceding two weeks. The researchers did not find a similar distinction in visits to stores, offices, gyms, salons, public transportation and churches.

On the date of the party, Napa County reported 32 new cases of COVID-19, 286 active cases, 2,181 confirmed cases, 16 confirmed deaths and 1,879 recoveries. The total has since risen to 2,623 cases.

Newsom publicly apologized for attending the dinner, saying he should have practiced what he preached. The same day, he announced tight new restrictions to combat a fall surge of the virus, including the closure of most nonessential businesses, restaurants, bars and places of worship. On Thursday, Newsom tacked on a month-long curfew shutting down non-essential work and gatherings from 10 p.m. to 5 a.m. for 94% of the state’s population.

There is some dispute as to whether the meal took place outdoors — Newsom said Monday that it was an outdoor restaurant, but photos published Tuesday by Fox LA appear to show a private dining room with at least three walls and a sliding glass door. Napa County was in the “orange” tier of the state’s reopening guidelines at the time, meaning some indoor dining was permitted.

Chin-Hong said a restaurant differs greatly from a school classroom, which are usually well-ventilated and require students to wear masks at all times. 

Even if customers are asked to put their mask on between courses or when not eating, “we’re primed to just continue to have a good time in a restaurant,” he said.

“You’re laughing, you’re talking, maybe you have alcohol, which is the case in the French Laundry — you’re generating aerosols,” he said. “Unless you have a very powerful ventilation system, it can be a risky proposition.”

He pointed to two well-documented cases of restaurant transmission in January — one in Guangzhou, China, that sickened 10 patrons of a poorly ventilated restaurant, and another during Lunar New Year celebrations at a hot pot restaurant in Hong Kong that left 11 people infected.

Dr. Anthony Fauci, the nation’s top infectious disease expert, told MSNBC in September that restaurants should be closed to indoor diners.

“When you have restaurants, indoors, in a situation where you have a high degree of infection in the community, you’re not wearing masks, that’s a problem,” he said. 

In a peer-reviewed study published in Nature this month, Stanford researchers used mobility data to show that a few superspreader events at points of interest — including restaurants — account for the vast majority of COVID-19 infections. Rather than full-scale lockdowns, the researchers recommend restricting occupancy at those high-risk locations. 

Dr. LaMar Hasbrouck, a public health expert and physician, said that models cannot fully reflect an individual’s risk because “risk is relative, and cumulative.” Still, he noted the indirect risk to the public posed by the optics of Newsom attending the dinner. 

“Optics can really pose an indirect risk, because it can convert or translate into non-adherence,” he said. “We’ve seen a lot of that with our current president.”

Hasbrouck said Newsom should have modeled different behavior by leaving the dinner.

“In any leadership role, certainly if you’re touching on public health or you’re touching on public policy, you really have to have a higher standard,” he said. “You have to make some of those compromises because you’re trying to lead by example.”


Follow us for more stories like this

CapRadio provides a trusted source of news because of you.  As a nonprofit organization, donations from people like you sustain the journalism that allows us to discover stories that are important to our audience. If you believe in what we do and support our mission, please donate today.

Donate Today  

    More about Coronavirus

  • NIAID-RML via AP

    Coronavirus In California: Latest Updates And Resources

    The coronavirus has impacted nearly every aspect of life in California and around the world. Here are resources and all our coverage at CapRadio and NPR.

 CoronavirusCALMatters

Coronavirus Newsletter

Get answers to your questions, the latest updates and easy access to the resources you need, delivered to your inbox.

 

Want to know what to expect? Here's a recent newsletter.

Thanks for subscribing!

We'll send you weekly emails so you can stay informed about the coronavirus in California.

Browse all newsletters

More Stories

Andrew Nixon / CapRadio

Newsom Recall Organizers Oppose Bill To Let Future Recall Targets Access Signature Lists

April 12, 2021

Jared Jones/Sacramento History Museum

New Meets Old As Sacramento History Museum Gains Social Media Fame

April 13, 2021

Courtesy of East Bay Regional Park District

Rattlesnake Season Has Arrived In Northern California: Here's How To Stay Safe.

April 16, 2021

Most Viewed

California Coronavirus Updates: Global COVID-19 Deaths Surpasses 3 Million

How To Get A Vaccine Appointment In California, And Other Things To Know About The Vaccine

Rattlesnake Season Has Arrived In Northern California: Here's How To Stay Safe.

5 Things You Need To Know About Federal Drought Aid In California

With Barrett On Supreme Court, California’s Church COVID Limits Are Being Overturned

We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter

Most Viewed

California Coronavirus Updates: Global COVID-19 Deaths Surpasses 3 Million

How To Get A Vaccine Appointment In California, And Other Things To Know About The Vaccine

Rattlesnake Season Has Arrived In Northern California: Here's How To Stay Safe.

5 Things You Need To Know About Federal Drought Aid In California

With Barrett On Supreme Court, California’s Church COVID Limits Are Being Overturned

Back to Top

  • CapRadio

    7055 Folsom Boulevard
    Sacramento, CA 95826-2625

    • (916) 278-8900
    • Toll-free (877) 480-5900
    • Email Us
    • Submit a News Tip
  • Contact Us

  • About Us

    • Contact Us / Feedback
    • Coverage
    • Directions
    • Jobs & Internships
    • Mission / Vision / Core Values
    • Press
    • Staff Directory
    • Board of Directors
  • Listening Options

    • Mobile App
    • On Air Schedules
    • Smart Speakers
    • Playlist
    • Podcasts
    • RSS
  • Connect With Us

    •  Facebook
    •  Twitter
    •  Instagram
    •  YouTube
  • Donate

  • Listen

  • Newsletters

CapRadio stations are licensed to California State University, Sacramento. © 2021, Capital Public Radio. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Website Feedback FCC Public Files: KXJZ KKTO KUOP KQNC KXPR KXSR KXJS. For assistance accessing our public files, please call 916-278-8900 or email us.