Skip to content
CapRadio

CapRadio

signal status listen live donate
listen live donate signal status
listen live donate signal status
  • News
    • topics
    • State Government
    • Environment
    • Health Care
    • Race and Equity
    • Business
    • Arts and Lifestyle
    • Food and Sustainability
    • PolitiFact California
  • Music
    • genres
    • Classical
    • Jazz
    • Eclectic
    • Daily Playlist
  • Programs + Podcasts
    • news
    • Morning Edition
    • All Things Considered
    • Marketplace
    • Insight With Vicki Gonzalez
    • music
    • Acid Jazz
    • At the Opera
    • Classical Music
    • Connections
    • Excellence in Jazz
    • Hey, Listen!
    • K-ZAP on CapRadio
    • Mick Martin's Blues Party
    • Programs A-Z
    • Podcast Directory
  • Schedules
    • News
    • Music
    • ClassicalStream
    • JazzStream
    • Weekly Schedule
    • Daily Playlist
  • Community
    • Events Calendar
    • CapRadio Garden
    • CapRadio Reads
    • Ticket Giveaways
  • Support
    • Evergreen Gift
    • One-Time Gift
    • Corporate Support
    • Vehicle Donation
    • Stock Gift
    • Legacy Gift
    • Endowment Gift
    • Benefits
    • Member FAQ
    • e‑Newsletter
    • Drawing Winners
    • Thank You Gifts
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Close Menu

Interview: Legal Scholar Says Newsom Recall Is Unconstitutional

  •  Randol White 
Saturday, August 14, 2021 | Sacramento, CA
Listen
/
Update RequiredTo play audio, update browser or Flash plugin.
Santiago Mejia/San Francisco Chronicle via AP, Pool, File

In this Aug. 11, 2021 file photo, California Gov. Gavin Newsom speaks during a news conference at the Carl B. Munck Elementary School in Oakland, Calif.

Santiago Mejia/San Francisco Chronicle via AP, Pool, File

Law scholars are questioning the constitutionality of California’s recall election process that Gov. Gavin Newsom is facing on Sept. 14. 

They say voters in California might not have an equal say in the outcome because election law states that Newsom can't run as a replacement candidate. That means it’s possible the governor is replaced by a candidate who earns fewer votes than he does.

Erwin Chemerinsky, dean at the UC Berkeley School of Law, made that argument in the New York Times on Wednesday.

CapRadio's Randol White spoke with Chemerinsky about the process and what the dean sees as flawed.

Interview Highlights

So the first paragraph of your Times piece says the most basic principles of democracy are that the candidate who gets the most votes is elected and that every voter gets an equal say in an election's outcome. What do you believe the upcoming recall election violates, with those principles?

On September 14th, voters will face two questions on the ballot. One is, should Gavin Newsom be recalled? And the second is if he's recalled which of the following candidates should be governor? The first question is decided by a majority vote. And if Gavin Newsom is removed from office, then the candidate who gets the most votes, even though not a plurality, becomes the governor. 

So the example we give in the piece is imagine 10 million people vote and 4.9 million, or 49%, want Gavin Newsom to be governor. He's removed. But then imagine on the second vote that no candidate gets more than, say, 18%, which is where the leading candidates are polling now. That person would get 1.8 million votes. So 4.9 million in my hypothetical, want Gavin Newsom, 1.8 million would want whoever gets the most votes. The 4.9 million don't get their choice for Governor, the 1.8 million do. That we believe violates the Constitution and the precept of one person, one vote.

In 2003, the only time a governor was successfully recalled in California history, the system worked and was constitutional in that case because of how the votes fell.

It's exactly right. In that instance, Arnold Schwarzenegger got more votes than those who wanted Gray Davis to stay in office. So under our analysis, that would be constitutional. Of course, that could happen here. It is theoretically possible that some candidate on the second vote could end up with more votes than those who want Gavin Newsom. But no polling suggests that's remotely possible. Either Newsom is going to win and stay in office or if he's voted out some Republican candidate with far fewer votes is going to end up as Governor.

Why was this not taken up during the process to gather signatures or earlier than one month out?

I don't have an answer to that question. Until my colleague and I were discussing this, we had not heard anyone raise this concern with regard to one person, one vote.

Is there a chance that the Supreme Court could step in? 

The Supreme Court repeatedly, in fact, more than just twice, has held that equal protection requires that every person's vote count the same. That's the principle: one person, one vote. It was initially articulated in those cases of the 1960s, but has been consistently reaffirmed since. If someone brings a lawsuit either now or if this happens after the election, I would imagine the courts would get involved.

For additional questions about the upcoming recall election, including the issue of write-in candidates, check out CapRadio's voter guide


Follow us for more stories like this

CapRadio provides a trusted source of news because of you.  As a nonprofit organization, donations from people like you sustain the journalism that allows us to discover stories that are important to our audience. If you believe in what we do and support our mission, please donate today.

Donate Today  

    More about Newsom Recall

  • Marissa Espiritu / CapRadio / AP FILE

    The Latest: Governor Gavin Newsom Defeats Recall Election

    Today is election day — California voters will decide whether or not to recall Gov. Gavin Newsom. Check this page for the latest news on the recall election and what happens next.
  • State Government
  •  

 Newsom Recall

Randol White

All Things Considered Anchor/Reporter

Randol White is an award-winning, accomplished, and well-rounded broadcast journalist with more than two decades of radio, television, web and print experience.  Read Full Bio 

 @RandolWhite  Email Randol White

Sign up for ReCap and never miss the top stories

Delivered to your inbox every Friday.

 

Check out a sample ReCap newsletter.

Thanks for subscribing!

Thank you for signing up for the ReCap newsletter! We'll send you an email each Friday with the top stories from CapRadio.

Browse all newsletters
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 

Back to Top

  • CapRadio

    7055 Folsom Boulevard
    Sacramento, CA 95826-2625

    • (916) 278-8900
    • Toll-free (877) 480-5900
    • Email Us
    • Submit a News Tip
  • Contact Us

  • About Us

    • Contact Us / Feedback
    • Coverage
    • Directions
    • Careers & Internships
    • Mission / Vision / Core Values
    • Press
    • Staff Directory
    • Board of Directors
  • Listening Options

    • Mobile App
    • On Air Schedules
    • Smart Speakers
    • Playlist
    • Podcasts
    • RSS
  • Connect With Us

    •  Facebook
    •  Twitter
    •  Instagram
    •  YouTube
  • Donate

  • Listen

  • Newsletters

CapRadio stations are licensed to California State University, Sacramento. © 2022, Capital Public Radio. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Website Feedback FCC Public Files: KXJZ KKTO KUOP KQNC KXPR KXSR KXJS. For assistance accessing our public files, please call 916-278-8900 or email us.