If your time is short:
- Caitlyn Jenner has become the target of political attention since declaring to run in the likely California recall election as a Republican challenger. Jenner has also received criticism for a fatal car accident that prompted her to pay settlements. Posts across Facebook and Twitter have suggested that Jenner recklessly killed someone in the streets.
- In 2015, Jenner was involved in the accident where she rear-ended a car into oncoming traffic, which caused the driver’s death. Jenner settled with several of the parties. However, the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department suggested Jenner be charged for vehicular manslaughter.
- After an investigation, the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office found there was no evidence to support whether Jenner was negligent or had broken any major traffic laws. Legal experts say proving these types of cases is difficult because the burden of proof relies solely on the prosecutor.
On the night of this year's Academy Awards, Olympic gold medalist and former reality TV show star Caitlyn Jenner got into a social media tussle with Democratic Congress member Ted Lieu of California.
The argument started on Twitter: As a way to win support for her candidacy in the likely recall election against Gov. Gavin Newsom, Jenner criticised the governor for allowing district attorneys to release “dangerous criminals back on to our streets.”
The Twitter war stole some of the spotlight from the Oscars and went viral. Alex Mohajer, a political commentator, retweeted Jenner’s criticism with the comment, “This is your reminder that Caitlyn Jenner literally killed someone in the streets 6 years ago and was released by a District Attorney.”
Mohajer also posted the claim to their Facebook, where it was shared more than a thousand times.
Facebook flagged the post as part of its efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about PolitiFact California’s partnership with Facebook and a previous PolitiFact fact-check of Caitlyn Jenner from 2017.) Facebook also flagged a similar post just days before.
We decided to look into it.
What happened:
In 2015, Jenner was driving an SUV, which was towing an ATV, on the Pacific Coast Highway in Malibu. She rear-ended a Lexus, pushing it into oncoming traffic. Kim Howe, the driver of the Lexus, was then hit by a Hummer traveling in the opposite direction. Jenner proceeded forward and hit another vehicle, a Prius, whose driver suffered mild injuries. But Howe was killed on impact.
Jenner was apologetic for the event and called it a terrible accident. She settled with Howe’s family and Jessica Steindorff, the driver of the Prius, for an undisclosed amount, as well as the family in the Hummer for $800,000.
The Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office issued an investigation into the accident and looked into the possibility of vehicular manslaughter. The investigation triggered controversy for Jenner at the time, because the misdemeanor charges would have potentially put her behind bars for at least a year, at which point she had just announced her gender transition.
At the end of the investigation, the DA’s office did not proceed with charges due to a lack of evidence. In order to prove vehicular manslaughter, a person must have some level of ordinary negligence. In Jenner’s case, they came up empty. The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department recommended that she be charged, however it wasn’t their final decision.
In addition to a lack of evidence, the DA's report said Jenner let go of the gas pedal and engaged her brakes a couple of seconds too late before hitting Howe. The report says she did not break any traffic laws, except for driving below the speed limit. Therefore, they declined to charge her with vehicular manslaughter.
Experts say charging someone for the crime isn’t easy. The burden of proof is entirely on the prosecution. California law says the prosecution must prove that the person who caused the death was driving with negligence and violating traffic laws.
“The negligence goes sort of hand-in-hand with the traffic offense,” said John McCurley, criminal defense attorney and appellate law specialist. Anything that can impair your driving safely — like texting, putting on makeup, or staring out the window — is considered ordinary negligence.
McCurley said these cases usually only involve single riders. “The only person who really has the story is them and they don’t have to testify,” McCurley said. “I think that’s a big issue with proving these cases.”
And if the prosecutor can’t come up with evidence, then they can’t press charges. “I can't say that it was her fault. So again, we have an absence of facts,” McCurley said.
When prosecutors do an investigation, they leave no shortage of expertise. “They don’t skimp on resources,” said Nabiel Ahmed, a criminal defense attorney in the Oakland Bay Area.
Ahmed represented a vehicular manslaughter case in which his client was intoxicated and driving over the speed limit. The driver did not engage their brakes and as a result smashed into a parked car. They were convicted.
“Caitlyn’s case differed [from] mine in that she did apply the brakes and she was driving below the speed limit, so these were two critical distinguishing factors,” Ahmed said. The investigation also found Jenner was sober at the time of the accident.
Our ruling:
Did California recall election candidate Caitlyn Jenner kill someone in the streets and get released by a district attorney?
It’s true that the district attorney did not pursue charges against Jenner. The decision came about after an investigation, in which the DA’s office said there was a lack of evidence to charge her with vehicular manslaughter and of driving recklessly. The DA did not release Jenner.
The posts on social media suggest that Jenner was released by a district attorney for killing someone. However, Jenner was never charged or convicted in the case.
We rate this claim Mostly False.
Sources:
Twitter post, April 25, 2021
Facebook post, April 25, 2021
Facebook post, April 26, 2021
JUSTIA, CALCRIM No. 593. Misdemeanor Vehicular Manslaughter
The Associated Press, Official: Video shows Jenner rear-ended cars in fatal wreck, February 18, 2015
CNN, Caitlyn Jenner won’t be charged in fatal four-car accident, September 30, 2015
People Magazine, Caitlyn Jenner to Pay $800,000 in 2015 Fatal Car Crash Settlement, January 26, 2018
YouTube video, Local 12 News, Feb 20, 2015
CNN, Second lawsuit filed over fatal wreck involving Caitlyn Jenner, June 9, 2015
YouTube video, Entertainment Tonight, September 9, 2015
Nabiel Ahmed, Criminal Defense Attorney, interview, April 30, 2021
John McCurley, Criminal Defense Attorney and Appellate Law Specialist, interview April 30, 2021
CapRadio provides a trusted source of news because of you. As a nonprofit organization, donations from people like you sustain the journalism that allows us to discover stories that are important to our audience. If you believe in what we do and support our mission, please donate today.