California Counts

A collaboration between Capital Public Radio, KQED, KPCC and KPBS to cover the 2016 elections in California.

 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 

California's GOP Senate Candidates Struggle for Attention

 Lisa Pickoff-White / KQED

Tom Del Beccaro, Duf Sundheim and Ron Unz (L-R), Republican candidates for Barbara Boxer's U.S. Senate seat.

Lisa Pickoff-White / KQED

Scott Shafer | KQED

When Republican Duf Sundheim showed up at the Democratic Party’s statewide convention in San Jose a few weeks ago, I was a little surprised to see him and asked him what he was doing there.

“Listening and learning,” Sundheim said, “and letting the people of California know that if I’m elected to the United States Senate I’m not just going to listen to the people who voted for me. I’m going to listen to all the people of California.”

Sundheim chaired the state party when voters recalled Democratic Gov. Gray Davis and replaced him with Republican Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Duf Sundheim

Duf Sundheim Lisa Pickoff-White / KQED

“I was chairman of the party for four years. I narrowed the registration gap between Republicans and Democrats to the narrowest it’s been since the 1930s,” Sundheim said. “I’m the chairman that actually won elections in this state.”

Of course he did that with more than a little help from Schwarzenegger, who changed the face and image of the party.

But conservatives have a disparaging name for moderate Republicans like Sundheim and Schwarzenegger: RINOs – Republican in Name Only.

But GOP consultant Hector Barajas calls that being flexible.

He [Sundheim] is willing to take in other viewpoints and at the same time compromise where it’s needed,” Barajas told me.

A Second, More Conservative Former Party Chair

Sundheim is running against another former party chair, Tom Del Beccaro. Unlike Sundheim, Del Beccaro signed a pledge not to support higher taxes. He also favors a strict interpretation of the Second Amendment’s right to bear arms, and he opposes holding Senate hearings for Judge Merrick, Garland, President Obama’s nominee for the U.S. Supreme Court.

“Tom Del Beccaro seems to be a little rigid and at the same time a little more conservative in his viewpoints,” said Barajas. “And there’s a way to do it, there’s not a way. For Del Beccaro it seems a little more black and white.”

Tom Del Beccaro
Tom Del Beccaro. Lisa Pickoff-White/ KQED

The centerpiece of Del Beccaro’s platform is a flat tax – one tax bracket for everyone while eliminating loopholes and tax breaks for corporations and others.

“John Kennedy cut taxes,” Del Beccaro says, trying to make his plan sound bipartisan. “Reagan cut taxes. Economics shouldn’t be partisan. It should be about understanding how economics work.”

Democrats see a flat tax as bad for the middle class. Del Beccaro says it would stimulate economic growth.

On immigration, Sundheim favors allowing eventual legal status for undocumented immigrants who meet certain guidelines. Del Beccaro frames another way.

“The Republicans in Congress need to stop pushing for a comprehensive bill that will turn into a Christmas tree or more likely a Pandora’s box,” he says. “So they need to shelve the comprehensive reform plan, that’s number one.”

Instead, Del Beccaro would focus on visitors who arrive on a visa and then go underground and stay here illegally. That he says is a national security threat.

The Wild Card Entrepreneur

The wild card in the U.S. Senate race was a last minute entry. Ron Unz, a tech entrepreneur best known for writing the ballot measure that banned bilingual education in California.

He’s for raising the minimum wage, and has been for a long time.

And at the state Republican party convention last weekend, Unz admitted – somewhat gleefully – that he’s hard to pigeon hole.

“You know sometimes I’ve been called a right winger, sometimes a libertarian. Sometimes even a liberal,” Unz told me. “People can call me whatever they want. But I’m very clear where I stand on each individual issue.”

Ron Unz
Ron Unz. Lisa Pickoff-White / KQED

Except on climate change, where Unz claims ignorance.

“All these claims going back and forth in the media this research group says absolutely true that climate change is correct. This other research group funded by different organizations says that ‘there’s no climate change.’ And I just don’t know.”

In other words, Unz sees no difference between research funded by fossil fuel companies and conservative think tanks and studies by the vast majority of climate scientists.

The biggest problem these three candidates face may not be the two Democrats who are well ahead of all of them in the polls. It’s fellow Republicans, like Ed Sachs from Mission Viejo.

“I would care more about the Senate race if I thought a Republican had a chance,” Sachs said at the state GOP convention recently. “But since I don’t believe that to be the case, I don’t want to say I don’t care. But perhaps I don’t care.”

Del Beccaro, Sundheim and Unz have less than a month to make voters care. The top-two vote getters on June 7 advance to the November runoff, even if they’re from the same party.

Read more in this series and let us know your thoughts on Twitter using the hashtag #CACounts.