Skip to content
Help us continue providing local, fact-based journalism
that keeps you informed and connected each day.
Support essential local journalism for your community.
General | News
Donate Now

View thank you gift options

CapRadio

CapRadio

signal status listen live donate
listen live donate signal status
listen live donate signal status
  • News
    • beats
    • State Government
    • Environment
    • Health Care
    • Business
    • Arts and Lifestyle
    • Food and Sustainability
    • PolitiFact California
    • California Dream
    • Videos
    • Photos
  • Music
    • genres
    • Classical
    • Jazz
    • Roots
    • Eclectic
    • Videos
    • Daily Playlist
  • Programs + Podcasts
    • news
    • Morning Edition
    • All Things Considered
    • Marketplace
    • Insight
    • California State of Mind
    • The View From Here
    • music
    • Acid Jazz
    • At the Opera
    • Classical Music
    • Connections
    • Excellence in Jazz
    • Hey, Listen!
    • Insight Music
    • K-ZAP on CapRadio
    • Mick Martin's Blues Party
    • Programs A-Z
    • Podcast Directory
  • Schedules
    • News
    • Music
    • ClassicalStream
    • JazzStream
    • Weekly Schedule
    • Daily Playlist
  • Community
    • Events Calendar
    • CapRadio Garden
    • CapRadio Reads
    • CapRadio Travels
    • Ticket Giveaways
  • Support
    • Evergreen Gift
    • One-Time Gift
    • Corporate Support / Underwriting
    • Vehicle Donation
    • Stock Gift
    • Legacy Gift
    • Endowment Gift
    • Volunteering
    • Benefits
    • Member FAQ
    • e‑Newsletter
    • Drawing Winners
    • Thank You Gifts
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Close Menu
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 

Proposition 46 Has Attorneys and Physicians At Odds

  •  Pauline Bartolone 
Friday, October 10, 2014 | Sacramento, CA
Listen
/
Update RequiredTo play audio, update browser or Flash plugin.
  

As the November election approaches, one state proposition has drawn the most money from top contributors. Proposition 46 would raise the cap on pain and suffering damages in medical malpractice cases. But, the measure could change the way doctors practice.  

Proposition 46 is actually three measures in one. It would require drug testing of doctors. It would require physicians to check a database before prescribing patients addictive substances. And it would raise the limit on damages awarded in medical malpractice suits. If that seems like a lot to take in, Consumer Watchdog’s Carmen Balber says the measure was deliberately written that way.   

“You write a measure so it will be successful at the polls," says Balber. "The stupidest thing you can do in an initiative campaign is write an initiative that the public doesn’t understand and doesn’t want."

But opponents say the measure is ‘carelessly thrown together.’

“This initiative is really about raising the cap, and everything else is just a distraction," says Dr. Ruth Haskins, with the California Medical Association.

The ‘cap’ is the $250,000 limit on pain and suffering awards in medical malpractice suits. It was set in 1975 under MICRA – The Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act.  Prop 46 would raise the cap to over $1 million. Haskins says that would make medical liability premiums go up.

“Physicians just won’t be able to afford to practice medicine in California," she says.

The California Medical Association says governments and taxpayers will pay more too. Haskins, who is a obstetrician and gynecologist, says it would make doctors like her change the way they practice to avoid lawsuits.

“If this passes, I might be saying, ‘let’s order that ultrasound now to see if there’s a problem’ and that ultrasound is going to be an increased cost to the medical health care system," says Haskins.

But attorneys say the current cap on damages already affects how they work. Sacramento law firm Kershaw, Cutter & Ratinoff says the cap forces lawyers to make business decisions about medical malpractice cases.

“We probably take 5 percent or less of the cases that are presented to us," says Attorney J.R. Parker.

He says it costs tens of thousands of dollars to build a case. So most of their cases involve the prospect of significant financial awards. Young people whose injuries have prevented them from working, or people who require lifetime medical care. MICRA does not cap those economic losses. Parker says he’s extremely selective about pain and suffering cases.

“Wrongful death cases are one of the best examples," he says. "Where, even if you’ve got a lost grandfather or a lost child, there’s no real loss of earning capacity that anyone could attach to that death. So the grizzly reality of MICRA is that those cases are only worth $250,000.”

Parker says those limitations don’t apply with other causes of injury.

“The same kinds of injury that happen to be caused by a defective product or a truck driver that falls asleep, or any number of circumstances where someone is negligent, doesn’t do what they were supposed to do, and someone is injured as a result, the jury gets to decide how much that injury is worth in terms of pain and suffering," he says.

Lifting the damage cap has been considered in the legislature without success.  Wesley Hussey, Government Professor at Sacramento State University says that’s typically the point at which proponents take a measure to voters. He says the drug testing and the prescription drug database aspects of Prop 46 are ‘sweeteners’ added to win public favor.

“So it’s really about changing MICRA, but we’ve found over the years that kind of complicated technical issues like that don’t work well with the voters, so proponents have found something that’s easier to talk about… kind of bring voters in on that issue, and they get what they really want, which is the change to MICRA," says Hussey.

He says ‘sweeteners’ aren’t inherently bad – but they don’t always work. They can confuse voters, and confused voters often vote no.  

“They’re very good at making decisions on social issues, where it’s just basically their values and their preferences, but kind of complicated and technical issues, voters don’t understand it," he says. "And throwing money around to scare them or convince them to vote for it, that’s how propositions work often sadly in California.”

Lifting the cap would allow attorneys to earn more money on cases. Doctors are concerned about costs to their industry. Both professions bring in an average salary of more than $150,000 a year.


Follow us for more stories like this

CapRadio provides a trusted source of news because of you.  As a nonprofit organization, donations from people like you sustain the journalism that allows us to discover stories that are important to our audience. If you believe in what we do and support our mission, please donate today.

Donate Today  

    More about election 2014

  • Election 2014

 election 2014prop2014Proposition 46

Pauline Bartolone

News and Features Editor

Pauline Bartolone has been a journalist for more than 15 years, during which she was Capital Public Radio’s healthcare reporter from 2011-2015. Her work has aired frequently on National Public Radio.  Read Full Bio 

Coronavirus Newsletter

Get answers to your questions, the latest updates and easy access to the resources you need, delivered to your inbox.

 

Want to know what to expect? Here's a recent newsletter.

Thanks for subscribing!

We'll send you weekly emails so you can stay informed about the coronavirus in California.

Browse all newsletters

More Stories

Andrew Nixon / CapRadio

As Students Return To Classrooms, One Group Is Noticeably Still Learning at Home: Asian Americans

April 9, 2021

Shae Hammond / CalMatters

California Oversight Of Nursing Homes Called ‘Befuddling,’ ‘Broken’

April 11, 2021

Jeff Pachoud/AFP via Getty Images

Can Vaccines Stop Variants? Here's What We Know So Far

April 10, 2021

Most Viewed

California Coronavirus Updates: Health Officials Say Not To Worry If You Got Johnson & Johnson Vaccine

California Coronavirus Updates: COVID-19 Vaccination Pop-Up Clinic At Luther Burbank High School On April 13

When Can I Get A COVID-19 Vaccine? How Will I Find Out? Answers To Your California Vaccine Questions.

Signatures Are In. What You Need To Know About The Gavin Newsom Recall Effort.

'What Is That In The Sky?' Floridians Catch Meteor's Close Brush With Earth

We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter

Most Viewed

California Coronavirus Updates: Health Officials Say Not To Worry If You Got Johnson & Johnson Vaccine

California Coronavirus Updates: COVID-19 Vaccination Pop-Up Clinic At Luther Burbank High School On April 13

When Can I Get A COVID-19 Vaccine? How Will I Find Out? Answers To Your California Vaccine Questions.

Signatures Are In. What You Need To Know About The Gavin Newsom Recall Effort.

'What Is That In The Sky?' Floridians Catch Meteor's Close Brush With Earth

Back to Top

  • CapRadio

    7055 Folsom Boulevard
    Sacramento, CA 95826-2625

    • (916) 278-8900
    • Toll-free (877) 480-5900
    • Email Us
    • Submit a News Tip
  • Contact Us

  • About Us

    • Contact Us / Feedback
    • Coverage
    • Directions
    • Jobs & Internships
    • Mission / Vision / Core Values
    • Press
    • Staff Directory
    • Board of Directors
  • Listening Options

    • Mobile App
    • On Air Schedules
    • Smart Speakers
    • Playlist
    • Podcasts
    • RSS
  • Connect With Us

    •  Facebook
    •  Twitter
    •  Instagram
    •  YouTube
  • Donate

  • Listen

  • Newsletters

CapRadio stations are licensed to California State University, Sacramento. © 2021, Capital Public Radio. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Website Feedback FCC Public Files: KXJZ KKTO KUOP KQNC KXPR KXSR KXJS. For assistance accessing our public files, please call 916-278-8900 or email us.